
Summarize with AI
Klaviyo builds loyalty by reacting to each customer's order history. This guide covers retention flows, RFM and VIP segments, predictive CLV and churn risk, Love Loyalty, Smile and Yotpo integrations, reviews, SMS, Klaviyo AI and how to measure repeat rate and cohorts, checked on November 8, 2026, with examples from Phytoceutics, GANT and Bernstein.
Klaviyo builds customer loyalty by turning your store's order data into messages that bring customers back for a second, third and tenth order. It doesn't run a points program itself. It decides who gets which message and when: a care guide after delivery, a reminder when a product is likely running out, early access for your best customers, a personal note before a high-value customer drifts away.
This article covers the retention side of Klaviyo: post-purchase and replenishment flows, VIP and RFM segments, predictive CLV and churn risk, loyalty app integrations (Love Loyalty, Smile, Yotpo), reviews, SMS, win-back and how to measure whether any of it works. Setup and the full list of flows are in our Klaviyo for Shopify guide, and loyalty apps are compared in our Shopify loyalty apps guide. wecanfly is an official Klaviyo partner. We checked every Klaviyo, Shopify and app feature below against their documentation on November 8, 2026.

Why retention starts with knowing who your best customers are
In most stores, a small group of customers brings in a large share of revenue, and retention work starts with finding that group. In our podcast episode on RFM analysis in Shopify (in Polish, with an English transcript; April 2026), Maciek described a client where 13% of customers generated more than half of revenue. The client didn't know Shopify had a report that showed it, and across other client admins we saw almost nobody using it.
That changes the question. Instead of "how do we send more emails?", it becomes "how do we keep these people, and how do we move the next group up?" Klaviyo is the tool that answers the second part, because it can react to each customer's order history automatically.
Before you change anything, write down your baseline. Marton Kosdi-Kovacs, co-founder of Love Loyalty, put it simply in our episode Beyond points: a deep dive into e-commerce loyalty programs (July 2026): measure what share of customers return, how often they come back and how many first-time buyers return, then compare the same metrics for the same customer group after twelve months.
Retention flows that bring the second order
The flows that build loyalty all start after the first purchase: post-purchase, replenishment, cross-sell and win-back. Stores often put most of their effort into people who haven't bought yet. As Tomek said in our episode Best Klaviyo flows for e-commerce (in Polish, with an English transcript; episode #41), stores often forget about the customer right after the purchase, even though repeat purchases drive much bigger growth later.
| Flow | Trigger | What it should do |
|---|---|---|
| Post-purchase | Placed or fulfilled order | Thank the customer, explain how to use or care for the product, ask for a review once it has arrived |
| Replenishment | Klaviyo's expected date of next order, or a fixed interval for consumables | Remind the customer before they run out, offer a subscription |
| Cross-sell | Time since purchase, or Klaviyo's best cross-sell date | Suggest the product that goes with what they bought |
| VIP | Customer enters a VIP segment or loyalty tier | Recognize the status with access or a reward, not only a discount |
| Win-back | No order for longer than your normal buying cycle | Bring them back, ask why they stopped, try another channel |
A few things we've learned building these flows:
- Education cuts returns. In episode #41 Maciek gave the example of Suitsupply, which sends suit care and fit guides after a purchase. A customer who knows how to use a product is less likely to send it back.
- Time replenishment from data. Klaviyo predicts an expected date of next order for each customer who has ordered, and you can use it as a flow trigger (Klaviyo Help Center). A monthly reminder for coffee or filters is a good start until you have enough data.
- Set the win-back threshold from your own orders. Three months without an order is long in fashion and short for furniture. Look at your average time between orders before you choose a number.
- Don't discount everyone. Your best customers will often buy anyway. Give them early access or a limited product and keep discounts for customers who need a reason to come back.
The timings and message order we use for each flow are in the Klaviyo for Shopify guide.
How a quiz and a subscription feed retention at Phytoceutics
For Phytoceutics, a South African supplement brand, the retention data starts before the first order. We moved the store from WooCommerce to Shopify and built a supplement selection quiz that's fully integrated with Klaviyo, so the answers drive personalized recommendations, automated emails and remarketing (case study). We also added subscriptions directly on product pages, with flexible delivery and discount options, to encourage regular purchases.
The lesson for any store: a replenishment flow is a reminder, while a subscription removes the need to remember. If your product is used up at a predictable rate, offer both. More on the models in our guide to e-commerce subscription models.
Using VIP and RFM segments to decide who gets which message
RFM segmentation groups customers by how recently, how often and how much they buy, so each group gets a message that fits. You can build it in Shopify or in Klaviyo.
Option 1: Shopify's RFM customer analysis report. Shopify scores each customer on recency, frequency and monetary value and puts them into 11 groups, from Champions to Dormant (Shopify Help Center). You can save a group as a segment and send it to Klaviyo. In the RFM episode Maciek explained the catch: the default integration creates a static list in Klaviyo that doesn't follow customers as they move between groups. His fix is two Shopify Flow automations per segment (customer added to segment, add a tag; customer removed, remove the tag) and a Klaviyo segment with the same name based on that tag.
Option 2: Klaviyo's own RFM report. Klaviyo's RFM analysis assigns each profile to a group such as Champions, Loyal, Recent, At Risk or Inactive and saves it as profile properties (current group, previous group, date of the last change) that you can use in segments (Klaviyo Help Center). It needs the Personalization add-on or Advanced KDP, and the same data minimums as predictive analytics below.
What to do with the main groups, based on what we recommended in the RFM episode:
- Champions: early access to collections, limited drops, VIP events or a request for user-generated content. Exclude them from cold-traffic ad campaigns, where they only cost money.
- At risk and Dormant: a win-back sequence with a discount (for example 10, 15 or 20%), a question about why they stopped buying, and a try on another channel such as SMS if you have consent.
- Active and Promising: cross-sell and subscriptions, to move them toward Loyal and Champions.
Bernstein's loyalty tiers built on order history
Tiers don't have to come from a points app. For Bernstein, a German bathroom furniture brand that sells to consumers and businesses from one Shopify store, we built a tag-based segmentation system for B2B customers. Each business customer gets one of four levels based on order history and automatically receives the discount assigned to that level (case study). It works as a simple loyalty program for wholesale customers.
Customer tags like these also sync from Shopify to Klaviyo, so the same tiers can drive segments and flows, for example a message when a customer moves up a level.
Predictive CLV and churn risk
Klaviyo's predictive analytics estimate each customer's future value, churn risk and next order date, so you can act before a good customer leaves. On each profile, Klaviyo shows (Klaviyo Help Center):
- historic CLV, predicted CLV for the next year and total CLV
- churn risk, estimated from order count and frequency
- average time between orders
- expected date of next order, which can trigger flows.
Predictions only switch on when your data is big enough. Klaviyo needs at least 500 customers with orders, at least 180 days of order history with orders in the last 30 days, and some customers with three or more orders. Klaviyo retrains the CLV model at least once a week.
Three segments we find useful once predictions are on:
- High predicted CLV, not yet VIP. Treat them like future VIPs: a welcome into the loyalty program, early access, a thank-you after the second order.
- High historic CLV, high churn risk. These customers spent a lot and are drifting away. Send a personal message from the founder or customer service before any discount.
- Low churn risk, high CLV. Leave them out of discount campaigns. They're buying anyway.
If your store is too young for predictions, use Shopify's RFM report instead. It covers your whole customer history, including customers who bought years ago.
Loyalty program integrations with Love Loyalty, Smile and Yotpo
Klaviyo sends the loyalty emails and SMS, and your loyalty app supplies the data: points, tiers and rewards. Most Shopify loyalty apps sync profile properties and events to Klaviyo, which you can use in segments, email content and flow triggers.
| App | What syncs to Klaviyo | Flow examples | Source (checked Nov 8, 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Love Loyalty | Points balance, VIP level, paid membership status; 15+ events such as points earned, rewards redeemed and point expiry | Points expiring, VIP tier approaching | Klaviyo Marketplace |
| Smile | Points balance, VIP tier, referral URL, member state; pre-built flows such as Points Earned on Order, VIP Tier Achieved and Points Expiry Warning | Points earned, new VIP tier, points expiring | Smile Help Center |
| Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals | Points balance, loyalty tier, birthday; events for points earned, rewards redeemed and a new tier | Reward reminders, tier upgrades, birthday | Yotpo Support |
Love Loyalty is the loyalty app we most often recommend to our clients. Whichever app you use, check two things before launch:
- Turn off the app's own emails once Klaviyo takes over. Smile's documentation says to disable the Smile email when the matching Klaviyo flow is live, so customers don't get both.
- Check where points appear. Klaviyo's paid Customer Hub can show a shopper's points, tier and rewards on your site, with documented integrations for Smile.io and Yotpo (Klaviyo Help Center).
In our first episode with Marton, loyalty and customer retention for Shopify brands (May 2025), he named the integration as a key test when choosing an app: "it's super important that it integrates well with other apps, especially with email tools like Klaviyo or Shopify Flow."
Loyalty campaigns that work beyond points
In the Beyond points episode, Marton described loyalty campaigns that Klaviyo can send from loyalty app data:
- Expiring points in a quiet period. Set points to expire in your slow season and send a "use them now" campaign to the customers who have them.
- Tier progress. Tell customers they're close to the next tier and what it unlocks.
- Zero-party data. Customers share their birthday, skin type, their dog's breed or their fit preferences to earn points. That data makes later Klaviyo emails more personal.
- A redemption check. Marton considers a 20 to 40% point redemption rate healthy. If you're above 40% month after month and profit isn't growing with it, the program rules give too much away.
How to choose an app is in our loyalty apps guide, and how to design tiers and rewards is in loyalty programs on Shopify.
Reviews as a retention touchpoint
A review request is the post-purchase message customers expect, and a bad review is an early churn signal. Ask once the product has arrived, when people are most willing to write. Klaviyo has its own Reviews product, and you can set up a flow that alerts customer service when a review is rated three stars or lower (Klaviyo Help Center). Klaviyo's free and Email plans include Reviews for 50 orders a month, and the Marketing plan has no order limit (Klaviyo pricing).
In episode #41, Maciek suggested two follow-ups:
- thank customers who leave a review, for example with a discount or loyalty points
- send negative reviews to customer service (for example to Slack) so someone contacts the customer personally.
SMS for loyal customers
Use SMS for a few high-value moments, not as a second newsletter. SMS needs its own marketing consent, separate from email, so collect it on purpose: at checkout, in a sign-up form or when customers join the loyalty program.
Moments where SMS fits retention:
- points about to expire
- early access to a drop for VIPs
- back in stock for a product a loyal customer asked about
- a win-back message for dormant customers who stopped opening email, which we suggested in the RFM episode.
On Klaviyo's free and Email plans, mobile messaging comes as $5 of credit per month. On paid plans, SMS is an add-on (Klaviyo pricing).
Klaviyo AI for retention (November 2026)
Klaviyo's AI can answer loyalty questions, draft retention campaigns and predict who to target, but a person still decides what reaches customers. The features that matter for retention:
- Customer Agent answers shopper questions with built-in skills for order tracking, returns and exchanges, subscription editing, product recommendations and loyalty. The loyalty skill looks up points balances, redemptions and rewards and needs a lookup connected to a loyalty provider such as Yotpo or Smile.io (Klaviyo Help Center).
- Composer, Klaviyo's AI marketing agent, drafts audiences, copy and timing from a brief. The free plan includes $5 of Composer usage a month; on paid plans it's an add-on (Klaviyo pricing).
- Predictive analytics (CLV, churn risk, next order date), described above.
We work with these tools inside our own process. AI agents draft segments, retention flows and loyalty campaigns from our guardrails, our knowledge of Shopify and Klaviyo and the practices we've collected across many client accounts. A person from our team checks every audience, discount and message and signs off before anything goes live. How that looks in practice is in the Klaviyo for Shopify guide.
How to measure retention with repeat rate, cohorts and CLV
Measure retention by what customers do over months, not by email opens. Klaviyo's flow reports show attributed revenue, but some of those customers would have bought anyway. These metrics tell you whether loyalty is actually growing:
| Metric | How to calculate it | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Repeat purchase rate | Customers with 2 or more orders divided by all customers in the period | Shopify's Returning customers report |
| Cohort retention | Share of customers who first bought in a given month and ordered again within 90 or 180 days | Shopify's Customer cohort analysis report; Klaviyo's cohort analysis (Personalization add-on) |
| Time between orders | Average days between a customer's orders | Klaviyo profile predictions |
| Customer lifetime value | Revenue per customer over their history, plus predicted value | Klaviyo CLV (historic and predicted) |
| Point redemption rate | Points redeemed divided by points issued | Your loyalty app |
| Revenue per recipient | Flow revenue divided by recipients | Klaviyo flow reports |
Klaviyo's Personalization add-on adds cohort, RFM, CLV and product analysis reports. It's priced by active profiles, starting at $100 a month for up to 13,500 active profiles, and it's included with Advanced KDP (Klaviyo Help Center). Shopify's cohort and returning customer reports are a good free starting point (Shopify Help Center).
Give it time. In the Beyond points episode, Maciek and Marton agreed that loyalty trends only become clear over a year or more, because too many outside factors overlap in the short term.
What we learned from client projects
Retention marketing only works on clean, consented data and a good experience after the purchase. Three projects show it from different sides:
- Phytoceutics: the quiz collects customer needs before the first order and passes them to Klaviyo, and subscriptions on product pages make the next order automatic (case study).
- GANT: GANT's Polish store runs Emarsys, not Klaviyo, but the groundwork is the same. We wired the data and consent layer (OneTrust, the Shopify Privacy API, Google Consent Mode v2) so the brand controlled its data and consents from the first hour live. We also automated standard returns on Shopify Flow, so they process end to end without reaching customer service (case study). A return that just works is part of keeping a customer.
- Bernstein: four discount tiers based on order history reward loyal business customers without a separate B2B store (case study).
FAQ
Does Klaviyo have a loyalty program?
No. Klaviyo sends loyalty emails and SMS and can show points through its paid Customer Hub, but points, tiers and rewards run in a loyalty app such as Love Loyalty, Smile or Yotpo, which syncs its data to Klaviyo.
Which Klaviyo flows build customer loyalty?
Post-purchase, replenishment, cross-sell, VIP and win-back flows. They all target customers who already bought, which is where repeat revenue comes from.
When does Klaviyo's predictive CLV switch on?
When you have at least 500 customers with orders, at least 180 days of order history with orders in the last 30 days, and some customers with three or more orders.
How do I measure whether Klaviyo improves retention?
Track repeat purchase rate and cohort retention before and after, over at least twelve months. Don't judge by attributed revenue or open rates alone.
Build retention with an official Klaviyo partner
Klaviyo is good at sending the right message at the right time. The hard part is deciding what those messages are: which customers matter most, which rewards they care about and which numbers prove it works. As an official Klaviyo partner, we set up Klaviyo for Shopify stores, from RFM segments and retention flows to loyalty app integrations and reporting.
