Michał Pieprzak (Ekomersiak): What Holds Back Your Store's Growth, Part 1
Why isn't your store achieving the expected results?
Episode in Polish, English subtitles available. Below: an edited English translation of the full conversation.
Michał Pieprzak, an e-commerce advisor and author of the Polish blog Ekomersiak.pl, talks to Tomek Runowicz and Maciek Czerniak about what most often holds back an online store's growth. He explains how he picks clients and why he walked away from well-paid projects, what margin and average order value a store needs to make a profit, and why dropshipping from a shared wholesaler rarely adds up. He shows how to find out who your customer really is (a survey and in-depth interviews), why an owner needs a 5–10 year goal, and how to run an honest competitor analysis: brand differentiators, messaging, checkout and pricing. This is part one of the conversation, published in July 2024, for owners and managers of stores that already sell but have stopped growing.
Key takeaways
- Michał starts with one question: who is your customer? Two fashion brands with a very similar range: the owner of one couldn't describe his customer beyond basic demographics, while the other listed demographics, challenges, problems and needs straight away. The second brand sold ten times more. (34:12, 35:02)
- Test the owner's assumptions with customers. In an Instagram poll, a brand owner was sure one answer would win, and 90% picked the other one: "Polish brand, made in Poland". (35:02)
- A survey works when it asks for honest answers outright. With shopping vouchers as a reward, customers wrote glowing praise; only after the brand added "honest feedback" in bold did it get comments it could act on. With a small subscriber list, in-depth interviews about the buying process work better. (37:20, 38:14)
- According to Michał, a 20–25% margin with an average order of about 150 złoty can't make a profitable store. A 40% margin is the minimum, and only with costs and marketing efficiency pushed to the limit; from 50% up there is real room to grow. A lower margin needs an average order above 1,000 złoty. (28:23)
- Dropshipping a standard product from a Polish wholesaler that hundreds of other stores also use fails in 98–99% of cases, in Michał's view: marketing eats 10–20% of an already thin markup, and operating costs still have to be covered. (18:55)
- More sales don't always mean more profit. A fashion brand with about 80 million złoty in annual sales and a margin above 60% made roughly the same profit as one of Michał's clients with about 10 million złoty in sales and a 15–20% profit. The first owner preferred his company at 30 million złoty, when it was more profitable. (45:30)
- A goal is more than a sales figure. Michał asks owners what they want to do with the company in 5–10 years: sell it, hand it to managers, build a team to run it? That decides what kind of profitability to build. (45:30)
- Brand differentiators have to be "idiot-proof", meaning customers understand them without explanation. "Quality products, qualified staff, made with passion" says nothing, in Michał's words. Fast shipping and free delivery are table stakes, not differentiators. (25:10, 49:46)
- Redo your competitor analysis, and do it honestly. Michał scores 3–4 competitors on a scale from −2 to +3: brand strategy, differentiators, social media, email marketing, UX and UI, pricing, and messaging across three stages (pre-purchase, sale, post-purchase). A market example: Zalando beat Answear in Poland with free delivery and returns while they were still new. (53:40, 55:49, 57:23)
- Checkout bugs can quietly kill sales. In one store the parcel locker map (about 70% of orders) kept loading forever; in another, checkout conversion fell by 50–60%, which a purchase path report in GA4 explorations revealed. (63:39, 65:08)
- With a low margin, segment your pricing: a traffic builder (a bestseller with a cut margin; in an online pharmacy, infant formula drove over a tenth of sales), standard products, and a profit generator such as a private label. Strong differentiators often sit hidden on the "About us" page, which few customers visit. (70:46, 72:02, 73:07)
Guest
Michał Pieprzak had, at the time of recording (July 2024), worked as an independent e-commerce advisor since 2020. Before that he worked at the brands Atlantic and Drogeria Natura and at the Dr Max pharmacy chain, where he built an online pharmacy from scratch. He writes the Polish blog Ekomersiak.pl and a weekly newsletter. In the conversation he mentions about 6,000 hours of work with e-commerce clients and 295 million złoty in added annual sales across his clients. He also taught in the Szkoła E-commerce course.
Hosts
Tomek Runowicz and Maciek Czerniak run wecanfly, a Shopify Premier Partner agency that helps established brands with complex migrations to Shopify Plus. Today our projects run with AI agents built into processes and guardrails we developed from experience across many builds, and an experienced person on the team signs off every change. The problems Michał describes (differentiators missing from product pages, checkout bugs, conversion drops visible in GA4) are what we check in a Shopify UX and usability audit and in Shopify conversion rate optimization.
For product page elements that carry your differentiators, see UI/UX Features Your Shopify Product Page Design Needs ASAP. For post-purchase emails that go beyond abandoned carts, read Klaviyo for Shopify: Guide to More Email Revenue. The conversation continues, among other things on marketing budgets and traffic channels, in Michał Pieprzak, Ekomersiak: What is hindering the growth of your store – part 2 (in Polish, with an English transcript).
Transcript
This transcript is based on the recording of this episode. We edited it for readability: we corrected transcription errors, punctuation, and merged sentences that were cut off mid-flow. We did not change the content, order, or meaning of anything said. Any errors or inaccuracies are our responsibility alone — not our guests'. If you spot something that needs correcting, email us.
Recorded in Polish and published on July 30, 2024; below is an edited English translation. Michał's figures and client examples are as of the time of recording. We removed repetitions and filler.
Who is Michał Pieprzak?
Tomek: Hi, and welcome to Flying with Shopify. Our guest in the studio today is Michał Pieprzak, an e-commerce consultant and advisor. He gained his experience at brands like Atlantic, Drogeria Natura and the Dr Max pharmacy chain. He also writes the blog Ekomersiak.pl, where he's happy to share what he knows about running online stores, and for a while now he's been consulting commercially. He advises many stores on how to grow faster and more efficiently. That's why I think he's the ideal person for our question today: what's holding back my store's growth? Enjoy the episode. Hi.
Michał: Hi, thank you. First of all, thanks a lot for inviting me, it's a real pleasure. It took us a while to find a date, but we finally made it, and I'm very glad. A bit about me: as you said, I've worked as a consultant and business advisor since 2020. I can briefly explain how that came about. In 2019 I already knew that working at Dr Max wasn't what I'd always dreamed of. It was mainly about a change in management and losing my autonomy. So I decided I had to get out and go out on my own, or at least give myself a chance. I gave myself six months. I was very lucky, no question about it, because as we all know, COVID came in February and March 2020. That's exactly when I started my business, and e-commerce exploded.
Tomek: Perfect timing.
Michał: So right away my path was, pardon the phrase, strewn with roses, in quotation marks, because it was still a big challenge, but it gave me a much more dynamic start. I also had a rule: I gave myself six months to grow my consulting to 60–70% of what I earned in the corporate world as a director. If I hit that goal, I could keep going and work in e-commerce. I'm now in my fourth or fifth year as an e-commerce consultant and advisor. By now I have about six thousand hours of work with clients, e-commerce clients only, so I think there's probably nobody in the Polish market who has put in that many hours. And this is important: it's not about me being so great. It's that by working through very different cases, mistakes and screw-ups, I draw conclusions that pay off on other projects. Over time that adds up to a pattern for how to grow an online store step by step. I also run an industry blog. I have to admit that I haven't updated it much lately. But I have a plan, and I'll say it openly: after a long break, I'm writing a new article.
Maciek: The newsletter goes out regularly.
Michał: The newsletter goes out regularly, every Thursday at 7:40 a.m. to my subscribers. I won't hide that I really enjoy it, because I know it gives people a lot of practical value. They write to tell me so, and my open rate shows it too: well above 50%, which I think is a very good result for any industry newsletter.
Maciek: Definitely. I feel people underestimate the power of a newsletter. They think it's a tool from the early days of the internet, but even in e-commerce it's a very effective channel if people like it.
Michał: More proof that it all depends on how you do it.
Maciek: Exactly.
Michał: Let me add right away that the newsletter is one of the main areas I focus on with clients. It's a great tool for building real relationships with customers and with people who haven't bought from us yet, because it engages them in a completely different way. There are no distractions like ads or social media. You can build a good message, and if you do it well from the start, you can gain a lot over your competitors. But we'll get to that.
How did a brand built from scratch reach 35 million złoty a year?
Maciek: I'd like us to start with a teaser, something that makes listeners want to hear the rest of the conversation. Could you tell us about your biggest, most spectacular success?
Michał: From zero to 35 million złoty in annual sales. It's a brand I've worked with for a little over three years, about 40 months. That's my best example of what working together can achieve: we started with a brand-new brand and grew it step by step.
Maciek: So the brand was built from the ground up.
Michał: From zero. Everything was built from zero, and it really worked. I certainly contributed as support, but the client's trust mattered enormously. He trusted me, believed in me, and on many things didn't even argue, he just went with it: "OK, we'll do it the way you say, Michał." That's a condition of any good advisory relationship. I don't even want to use the word "consultant"; I wouldn't call myself that. I'm someone who helps people grow their businesses and their online stores. "Consultant" sounds pompous to me; I just help good people grow their businesses. This is very important to me: the client's values have to match how I approach things. Of course I'm one part of it, and on the other side is the client, who has to do all the work. I've often walked away from projects myself, even when it was a really good, big brand with potential. For example, one e-commerce business was doing 140 million złoty a year at the time, and I ended the collaboration.
Maciek: Because they weren't doing what you'd agreed on.
Michał: They weren't. I can even give you the example that decided it, and as people who build online stores, you'll understand it perfectly. We were building a new version of the store, desktop and mobile. That was roughly three, three and a half years ago, so mobile already mattered a lot. Someone on the team says: "We'll carry the desktop over to mobile, make it responsive and it'll be fine." And I say: "No, that's absurd. We need dedicated mobile views, because mobile is going to dominate." The balance was already tipping toward mobile, even in revenue, whereas before people only talked about users. I realized then that if that's how they approached it, there was nothing to talk about. I'll say it plainly: I ended the collaboration myself. It was very well paid, and they would have kept paying me, because they wanted me on the project. The owner was an investment fund, and they asked me to continue. I said it made absolutely no sense.
Maciek: That's a bold move. Most people probably wouldn't do it; they'd just sit there, dial into the calls and take the money.
Michał: No, I have a basic rule: I look in the mirror and have to be able to say whether I'm doing good work and helping these people, or whether it's a stretch, adds nothing and I'm taking money for it. The second option is absolutely not acceptable to me. That's my value system, and maybe that's largely why I get results with my clients.
Who does Michał work with, and who does he turn down?
Maciek: We'll probably come back to that. Before we turned on the mics and cameras, you mentioned that you don't work with every company. Leaving aside that you're busy and short on time, you said you have certain selection criteria. Can you tell us about them?
Michał: Absolutely. The basic criterion is goals: what is the client aiming for? If their goal is, let's say, modest sales, and I don't want that to sound arrogant, because for many people 100,000 złoty a month in an online store is a very good result, while from my perspective we're only just taking off… If I hear that's the growth goal, and I mean for a store that's just starting, that horizon doesn't fit my assumptions. My time is very limited. I have many more people wanting to work with me than I can handle, so I want to do projects where we can get very good business results, in the solid millions and tens of millions of złoty. Let me just add that my own goal, which everyone calls very ambitious, is to grow my e-commerce clients' sales by a billion złoty. Right now it's 295 million złoty in added sales per year, which I think is pretty decent for a small guy like me.
Back to the criteria: the goal, definitely, because it sets the direction. But the key criterion is, I'd say, chemistry with the client. I won't hide that I have the comfort of working with the people I want to work with, who share similar values. I have turned down, literally, owners who appear as guests on business YouTube channels. I said no because the way they behaved was unacceptable to me. That's not how I operate. I try to respect every person, and it makes no difference to me whether it's the CEO of a store doing 200–250 million złoty a year or a cleaner. It makes absolutely no difference.
It always starts with a first meeting, once the client has made it through the sieve. And I should add that the sieve is very tough from the start, because the average wait to start working with me is between 6 and 12 months. That also shows me how determined the client is: they keep pushing and don't give up. Then I know I can really achieve something with them, because they'll stubbornly carry out the actions we define later and want to achieve together. That's where my best collaborations come from.
On values and chemistry, I can simply tell whether we get along and see things the same way. I've started to rely heavily on intuition, because I had a few projects that didn't work out. I mentioned one of them before we started recording. After a conversation of even 30 minutes, with questions about what we're aiming for, what we want to achieve, how we'll get there and how open the client is to a concrete plan and actions, I know whether we'll deliver. I haven't taken on new clients for a long time, because I keep working with the ones I have. I still have two clients I've worked with since I started, so more than four years, so it can't be too bad if they still put up with me. That's the chemistry and relationship part: I want to enjoy the work, and I want the other side to enjoy it too. Those two things, goals and values, decide whether the collaboration is really good. Over time it turns out that with chemistry and a good, ambitious goal, we get there together, because we see things in a very similar way. I think that's it on selection.
Tomek: I think so. To dig into selection a bit more: do you automatically turn down projects because of the industry or the type of business?
Michał: Definitely. Here's an example. An owner who planned to sell dietary supplements got in touch with me, some extraordinary collagen from Switzerland, as he put it. I checked the ingredients. They were identical to a Polish collagen, only 300 or 400% more expensive. I'll say it plainly: I knew straight away we wouldn't work together, because it's very important to me that I'd buy the client's product myself.
Tomek: OK.
Michał: That's one of the factors, and thanks for asking, because you've touched on something very important: I'd want to buy and use the product myself. Aga benefits a lot from this, because among my clients there are three fashion brands.
Tomek: I can see where this is going.
Michał: And I can tell you she has clothes from all of them.
Tomek: Great! It often happens with us too: happy clients send gifts at the end of the year, to us, to the team or to the project managers.
In general, it seems to me that what you're describing is a feedback loop between you and the client that has to happen. You need to feel that there's a partner on the other side who wants to make it happen with you. For you, it starts with convincing yourself first: about the product, the client, the store, and looking for the potential. Then of course you keep growing it, but without that base, without trusting the product itself, it's hard to build anything, right?
Why does dropshipping rarely add up?
Michał: Exactly. I'll say it again: I look in the mirror and know I'm not selling junk or helping grow some scam or shady business. When I say "scam", what comes to mind is the internet MLM of e-commerce, dropshipping. I'd say it has no chance in 98–99% of cases, because the basic numbers don't work. If you take the margin and a standard product, the same one that 800 other stores connected to the same wholesaler have, it simply can't work. Yet people build a vision of a very simple business model where you make big money and become financially independent. If you have some unique, wonderful niche, maybe. But if you're connected to a Polish wholesaler along with lots of other stores, it can't work. Just calculate the store's budget, and we'll probably get to that later: marketing costs of 10–20% eat the margin straight away. And where's everything else? Where are the operating costs, the staff costs? Even if you do everything yourself, it doesn't add up, and as a business it can't work. I may make some enemies, especially among people who offer these products and sell the platforms that go with them. I'd really like them, and I'm open to this, to share transparently what percentage of stores break even and are profitable, and what percentage are really just supplying capital.
Tomek: That's right.
Michał: What tempts people who go into it is the vision of easy money.
Tomek: And how simple the business looks.
Michał: Yes. It's a bit like a gold rush: shovels sell best, and the people who do best are probably the ones teaching how to do dropshipping.
Tomek: Yes. We also had a client in a dropshipping business who probably spent most of his team's energy removing negative reviews, because people were disappointed with both the quality and the delivery time. Somehow the site forgets to mention that the product will take two, three, four weeks to arrive.
Michał: That's business suicide right away. Communication and differentiators are part of the whole business and e-commerce strategy for growing a brand. We'll probably get into those threads later, but the foundation of why my clients succeed is a well-thought-out e-commerce strategy for growing the whole brand, with a long-term view: where we want to be and who we are. There's one very important question I always ask, probably one of the first: why should a customer buy from you and not from a competitor? And how do you communicate that at every touchpoint with your brand? It's a very simple question, but if listeners or viewers of this episode ask themselves, they'll see the answer isn't that simple. When I ask it, nobody can answer quickly. Why should a customer buy from you and not from a competitor?
Which stores come to Michał for advice?
Tomek: It takes effort and work to think that through. But we'll get there. Let's talk now about what businesses come to you and with what problems, so we go step by step. Are they usually companies at the start of their journey? Ones that have gotten stuck? Small or large?
Michał: It varies a lot, because most of my clients are ones I've worked with for a long time. As I said, I don't take on new clients because I don't have the capacity, and since my current clients are happy and don't want to stop, we keep going. Most of them are stores that have been on the market for a good few years. Before we started working together, they'd often been around for four or five years, but things weren't going the way they should. A good example is a fashion brand that had been on the market for three or four years. When we started, it was doing about 45,000 złoty a month. We grew it in stages, and now it averages about a million złoty a month. I think that's a pretty good result, though I know the brand has the potential to go much higher. I'm not sure if I answered your question or drifted off a bit.
Tomek: You partly answered it. What I take from your answer is that a large share of your clients are businesses that have gotten stuck in their growth, but come to you with some experience already.
Michał: Yes. I'll add brand-new brands where I see great growth potential. I have two right now that joined me over the last year or year and a half. We share the goal of building something really strong, hopefully over time. One is in furniture, and the other is what I'd call sports fashion.
Tomek: OK, I think I know which one you mean.
Michał: Quite possibly you know who it is. Those key conditions are there: the people simply want it. Because I'm not a wizard or a fortune teller who produces results: we start working together, I say "do this, this and this," and it takes off. To get results, there's a huge amount of work on the client's side, our joint work. You have to go through the stages of implementing the strategy, and we'll certainly talk about that, and build a brand on a very strong foundation: one that knows who its customer is, knows its competitors, and only then shows what it should, its advantages and differentiators. And has them clearly defined. Dear listener, dear viewer: I'd bet that if I asked you what your differentiators are, you'd say "fast shipping, free delivery." That completely misses the point. Those are e-commerce table stakes you have to have. Without them you lose in the market. We're talking about the differentiators of your brand compared with everyone else, so that you stand out in messaging and visually.
That makes three brands, because I forgot one: a client in gardening. I was talking to Hubert recently. I asked: "What are you aiming for? What do we want? What scale?" He already has quite a nice scale of sales, about half a million a month and up, so a good base for growth. I told him: "So you probably want to be the Apple of gardening, right?" That's what I mean: building a very strong, distinctive brand. On top of that, he has a really good product, which is why we work together, because I'd like to have that product in my own garden. There are many more variables, but it's about the brand being distinctive visually and in its messaging: in the copy and in a communication style developed for our target customer.
When does a business have no chance of adding up?
Tomek: Before we move on to the growth plan, I wanted to ask: have you come across a case where the business that came to you made no sense at all? Where the numbers were wrong and whatever you did, it had no chance, like those dropshipping stores? Or a case where you reached a dead end with a client and felt a bit helpless?
Michał: With my current clients I don't have that, because I know there's still a lot of potential. That's why we work together. But with new clients who've come to me for a consultation, there's one key criterion. When I hear a margin of around 20–25% and an average order of, say, 150 złoty, I'll say it plainly: I know it can't succeed, because you can't build profitability out of that. Unfortunately it makes no business sense. I once worked through and analyzed what margin an e-commerce business needs for it to make business sense at all and for you to really be able to do something with it. 40% is the point where you have to push hard and have cost optimization and marketing efficiency turned up to the maximum. But honestly, from 50% up there's comfortably a lot of room to grow. Is it possible with a lower margin? Of course it is, but then the average order has to be much higher, in the thousands of złoty, at least above a thousand, because once you calculate the margin in money terms, something still has to be left to cover all the costs.
Tomek: There are also businesses where, I think, it's a matter of scale: you run on a very low margin and make all your profit from, say, having negotiated good terms with logistics. Have you heard of cases like that?
Michał: Could you say that again?
Tomek: We're at a scale where the margin on the product is very low, and we actually make money where…
Michał: On the logistics spread. Yes, it happens, but it's what I'd call an unusual business model, and none of my clients have it. More often it's solved by, for example, using Wygodne Zwroty, and I don't know if I'm advertising anyone here or not, to split the costs: we pay part, the customer pays part. I mean returns, so they don't generate extra losses, and quite a few companies are going that way.
Back to which stores I won't take on. I mentioned the ones selling some scam or without potential. There are also brands that have hit the maximum in their niche, where it's really hard to go further. There are niches where 300,000 złoty a month in e-commerce is the ceiling; you won't get past it. Then the business question is: do we expand the range, while keeping it consistent with the whole offer, or go in a completely different direction? Recently, in the Szkoła E-commerce group, someone asked me: he has two online stores with a similar range, both selling something. What should he do with them, given he has double costs: marketing, running ads and so on? Merge them and build one brand? Or keep them separate because, for example, given the pricing, one has a higher margin and the other a lower one, but the higher-margin one offers extra services, better advice and so on? That's a tough business decision. In that situation I'd choose to build one consistent brand, with the assumption that we push up the margin. Because again: we buy brands, and we often don't look at the price if the brand is distinctive and strong enough that we don't consider any alternative.
Where to start? With the question of who your customer is
Tomek: Listen, Michał, I have a question, because in a moment we'll probably go through your method step by step: where you start and what it should look like. But as a teaser, from your experience: you've had the first meeting, you're getting to know the brand and its problems. Clients probably most often come because they want to sell more, be more profitable and ultimately earn more. Do you have a pattern like: "OK, I'll usually start with this one element anyway, because I know it'll be the biggest lever right from the start, or it's where I most often see problems, and we'll fine-tune everything else later"? Is there one area like that?
Michał: Absolutely there is. It's the key element that 99% of online stores, maybe more, play down and neglect. A simple question: who is your customer?
Tomek: OK, so just identifying them.
Michał: Who is your customer? What challenges do they have? What problems? Who is your target group? Let me share two examples. Two fashion brands, so the same industry. At one, when I asked, "Please tell me who your customer is," the owner went around in circles: 20, 30 years old, big city, small town, whatever. Only basic demographics. A brand that had been on the market for several years couldn't tell me plainly who its customer was. At the other, when I asked the same question, they immediately started listing demographics, challenges, problems, needs, everything. Do you know what the difference in sales was? How much more did the second brand sell?
Tomek: Ten times more?
Michał: Exactly ten times more. Very similar brands, very similar ranges, but knowing your customer makes a colossal difference. Everyone thinks they know who their customer is. But then I ask: "OK, and how do you check who your customer is, what challenges and needs they have?" "Well, I just know." In one case, to make sure, we used Instagram and gave two options: which is the more important differentiator of our brand for you? The owner was convinced one option would win, and 90% chose the other. I can even tell you what it was: "Polish brand, made in Poland." Obvious, you'd think, and it turned out to be a very important factor for people. So how wrong can we be about who our customer is, if we're wrong about something like this, and not by 5 or 6% but by a crushing margin?
Surveys and in-depth interviews to find out who your customer is
Michał: I can share how I approach it, because after the "why" question, the next one is exactly that: who is your customer? We get there in stages, together with the client, and analyze their customers' needs. You can do it two ways. The first is a survey, and you can offer a nice incentive for it. We build a whole survey made of several sections, blocks, where we focus on questions like: why do you choose our brand? Why do you choose a competitor? What would make you buy our brand? What should we communicate in our industry for you to buy from us? They seem simple, obvious, basic. Nobody asks them.
Tomek: And when someone does, they can't believe what they find.
Michał: Yes. I'm smiling because I remember doing survey after survey, and most often I heard: "No, some survey, nobody will fill it in, nobody will want to, or I'll have to give something for it," and so on. But if we do it really well… Let me say this right away to listeners and viewers who want to run a survey like this: focus hard on making it clear that you need honest answers, not glowing praise. We've been through the version where the survey came with three shopping vouchers, gift codes, many times. It turned out to be the most beautiful, best online store…
Tomek: They read it as: the better they write, the bigger the reward.
Michał: Yes. The best online store in the world. But if we ask for honest answers… That's exactly what happened with a client: first came the praise, and after a while we updated the survey and put it in bold: honest feedback, that's what we'll reward. Maybe not hateful, but brutally honest, because only then can we, as store owners, change and improve something. Surveys like that really do produce gold.
Of course you need a base for this. Every store is at a different level: a subscriber list might have 100, 200 or 500 people, or it might have tens of thousands, so getting a representative sample can be hard. The second option is in-depth interviews. They're hugely valuable: talking to a customer and asking: "What was the buying process like? What's missing on the site? How did you go through the purchase? What wasn't there? What else should we communicate?" That's gold, and nobody uses it at all. I think e-commerce isn't complicated. It's very complicated for someone just getting into it. But if we start breaking it down step by step and do it the right way, over time we can build real advantages and differentiators for our brand in the market.
Yesterday, in a reply to a newsletter where I wrote about email marketing, someone told me this works great for manufacturer brands. I disagree. Multi-brand stores can gain a lot from it too. For example, I now have a client in an unusual industry, agriculture. We're at the beginning, though we've been working for a while. Agriculture is generally behind when it comes to online and e-commerce, there's a lot to do there, and the newsletter and advice alone offer huge possibilities. Thousands of products, a very wide range. If from the start we approach it with a message and build a good relationship, then right after the newsletter signup we don't send the standard "Thanks for subscribing. 5% off your first order. Use it now!" That gives no value at all. It just trains the customer: "Oh well, 5% off. I'll never come back, but there's 5% off." Can't we approach it a bit differently? Right after signup: "Hi, this is the brand we are. This is what sets us apart. We started because…" Show a human face. Because in e-commerce I don't even split it into B2C and B2B. For me it's simply person to person.
Tomek: In B2B there's a person on the other side too.
Michał: Yes. And in the end we sell to a person. People often forget that. Back to your question: if you break down who your customer is, you're already way ahead of the competition. Really way ahead, because nobody does it.
Tomek: Is it some kind of phenomenon? In your view, does it come from not seeing the value at the start, not being aware of it? Or rather from the attitude: I'm the founder, I know best?
Michał: Yes! That's exactly it.
Tomek: That's really interesting.
Michał: He thinks, or feels, that it's exactly the way he believes. And then come the questions about customers' needs and challenges. We can later use those challenges and needs in all our messaging. We have a marketing strategy: an analysis phase, a strategy phase for building the brand, and then a communication phase, the communication strategy. In that last phase we can show those challenges and problems beautifully in ads and materials: "Hey, we know you have these problems, we know you face these challenges." Put it in bold so it comes through. But again I'm laughing, because I said e-commerce isn't complicated. On the other hand, it is, because I'm talking about it, but you have to build a whole structure for it, a sales funnel. We split it into cold and warm traffic. What do we say to someone who doesn't know us at all? First we have to build a relationship and a message with them, and only then offer something, not: "Hey, buy now! Great deal!" Sorry, but that's…
Tomek: Not the way to go.
Michał: Not the way to go, it doesn't work like that. The topic of who my customer is could be explored much deeper, going precisely into what a survey should contain. Believe it or not, I see this in Szkoła E-commerce when we work with participants: there was a module on it, and we had extra live sessions where people asked how to do it. I thought: it's just a survey, you ask questions as simple as can be. And it turned out that making a really good survey isn't easy at all. People needed to think it through and see how others approach it. Only after we'd worked through many examples did they understand what has to be in the survey for it to give real value to the founder, the owner or the e-commerce manager. Because I mostly work with owners, and on selected projects with managing directors or e-commerce managers.
Why is e-commerce a marathon, not a sprint?
Tomek: We've opened a few big threads, and now I'd like us to try to put them in order. You often write in your newsletter, and I really like the phrase, that e-commerce isn't a sprint but a marathon. I think it would be very useful for our listeners to think about how to prepare for that marathon and how to pace yourself. Where do you start?
Michał: The first thing is the goal. What are you, the store owner, really aiming for? And it's a goal in many dimensions. It can be purely business: I want to do 30 or 50 million in annual sales. But even when I get to those 30 or 50 million… A very well-known fashion brand in the Polish market came to see me for a consultation, about 80 million in annual sales. It's one of the few clients who came to me in person, because I usually meet online. The owner had reached the stage where he wants to sell the company. In short: build profitability, a really nice EBITDA, so that a fund or a company buys it. Does any owner, while growing a brand step by step, ask whether they want to run it for 10, 20, 30 years? Whether at some point they'll want to, pardon the phrase, cash in on the brand and sell it? Succession? Nobody thinks about it, but I ask about that too: what do you want to do with this store? Let's say everything goes according to our goals and plans, and in 5 or 10 years you're doing 50 million a year. What next? Because people also get bored and tired of it, and they think: "I'd like to try something else." Then, besides the business goal, there's the question of what we want to do: sell, run it on autopilot, hand the business over? Or maybe we'll focus on growing another business, so we have to build structures and a team that will run this company.
Believe it or not, with the client I mentioned, I can share this: I was very surprised. A fashion brand with a very good margin, above roughly 60%, and very little left over as profit. What was really valuable for me was what the owner said: "I liked my brand much more two years ago, when it was doing about 30 million a year, because I had much better profitability and much more influence on the business, and now the organization has started to sprawl." It's worth thinking about, because there's this hype: we have to push, we have to do things, grow the store. By contrast, I have a client doing about 10 million in annual sales with a 15–20% profit. At 10 million in sales versus 80 million, she's almost at the profit level of that big fashion brand. That's something really worth thinking about. But back to goals: what are we aiming for over one, two, five, even ten years? With the current pace of technology, ten years is a distant horizon, but over one, two, three, five years: where do we want to be?
Differentiators customers understand without explanation
Maciek: A question here, because the financial goal is obvious to everyone. In our experience, when we talk to clients about the company's mission and vision, people often struggle: they want to make money, but on the website they'll write that they want to make the world a better place. Do you have examples like that?
Michał: Well, you've just described empty filler. I laugh at it: we have quality products, qualified staff, we do it with passion. That's all empty filler. We'll probably get to strategy, but here I'd say: have differentiators. First of all, ones that are idiot-proof in your messaging, understandable to everyone. I very often laugh when an owner says, "So we'll use these slogans," and I tell him: "Now look: you're on the other side, you're the customer, read these slogans."
Maciek: Does it mean anything to him at all?
Michał: "You know what, Michał? Empty filler." They add nothing, or they're such sophisticated phrases that the owner and his team understand them, but the customer has no way of understanding them. Back to mission and values: they're the result of work done inside the organization. To be honest, I don't get into mission and values. Of course I can help, but it's the organization's internal core, which it should work out itself. Take the client from the agriculture industry. He asked me: "Michał, OK, now we're doing the strategy and the differentiators." And I asked: "But tell me, what do you have defined in the company? A vision, a mission, brand archetypes? How do we want to reach people, and with what message?" "We have nothing." "So how are we supposed to define your brand's differentiators now, when internally none of this exists and hasn't been worked through?" Recently he had a strategy workshop at his company, and the person running it said: "Very good, because you first have to do this internally, in the organization, and only then add it to your online strategy, to what you'll communicate and how." It's internal work for the whole team, not just the owner. A very common mistake is the owner saying "I know best," when it turns out the salesperson who works with customers knows 20 times better what it's really like: what challenges and problems customers have and what should be used. I can certainly help with that too, no problem, but it shows how much the strategic perspective matters.
Along the way, this client had also worked with two other training companies, and, to be honest, they're well-known brands. I won't name them, because I'd go through the roof, for a simple reason: they did an analysis without any numbers to show it's one way or another, without a customer survey, without questions. "We know everything": within the team alone, they started building the whole brand plan without considering the customer's perspective. What kind of strategy can come out of that?
How Zalando won with free delivery, or why you need competitor analysis
Michał: So, first the goal; that's probably enough on goals for now. Then the question of who your customer is. And the third very important element is competitor analysis. It sounds like a total cliché and something obvious, but in practice it turns out someone did it at the start, when the brand or multi-brand store launched five, six, seven years ago, and that's when they checked who the competitors were. And in e-commerce, as everyone knows, a lot changes in seven years. A good example is that in Poland we had a big multi-brand fashion store, Answear. Then Zalando arrived. Of course Zalando's budget and capabilities were on a completely different level. But how did they win? With their communication USP: free delivery. Back then it was still a total novelty.
Maciek: Now they're pulling back from it a bit.
Michał: Yes, now they're moving away from it a lot, but at that stage it gave them a very strong competitive advantage. Backed by brand awareness, of course, because huge budgets went into advertising across all media, including TV.
Maciek: When they started, I think they assumed from the outset that they'd only break even after about six years, something like that, right?
Michał: Yes. I also used to say it was a company that would never be profitable. But they reached break-even, and things started growing nicely for them. Of course they're making some changes now, but my point is that when they entered the market, Answear was there and was very afraid of it. I understand that from a business point of view, because suddenly free delivery was a total novelty. And free delivery plus free returns, because that was a differentiator. Answear introduced it later, but in people's minds it was already deeply rooted that Zalando was the one offering free delivery and returns. And then it was very hard for Answear to…
Maciek: Because it later became an e-commerce standard, and everyone tried to catch up with them.
Michał: Yes.
Maciek: But Zalando really was the first.
Michał: Answear introduced it, I don't remember exactly and I don't want to get it wrong, but much, much later than Zalando. And Zalando was number one in the Polish market then. There are of course many more factors, but my point is to show advantages and differentiators.
What should a competitor analysis cover?
Michał: My approach to competitor analysis is that we have a template we've developed with clients, with very different areas step by step: brand strategy, social media strategy, communication strategy, email marketing strategy, UX. UX and UI, let's separate them. Let me clarify straight away, because I've learned that when I say "UX and UI," people think: "What is this guy talking about?" UX is where things are, how elements are laid out on the page, and UI, the user interface, is then the colors and what ultimately gives you a good look and feel. I caught myself many times saying: "UX, UI, you know, right?"
Maciek: That's probably the curse of knowledge: when you work in the industry, you just…
Michał: And I know that more than 90% of the people listening don't distinguish between the two. They don't really know what it's about. But these are two stages of good online store design. OK, because I could go on all evening.
Maciek: Of course, let's keep going.
Michał: Let's stick to competitor analysis and go through it in order. Brand strategy: how competitors present themselves, whether they're consistent in ads, on the site, in all their messages. Then differentiators and advantages: are they clear? I always encourage making them graphic plus text, because an image with text is much more intuitive. And you can use them in many places. For example on the product page, which in most online stores today gets as much as 70% of traffic. Let's stand out there. You can split them: store differentiators, the basics, so free delivery, fast shipping, free returns, and then the brand differentiators proper: Polish brand, expert advice. Of course I'm oversimplifying a lot, because you have to work them out so that someone reading thinks: "Oh wow, they have this. Great. I struggle to choose a product, so if I can call and ask, that makes a difference." Even fast shipping can be presented differently. Most often there's a countdown timer on the product page. That's one option, but you can communicate it another way, for example: 99.9% of parcels arrive the next day. Here too you can break the pattern everyone uses.
The competitor analysis also covers pricing and all the elements that affect how the customer sees us. We do the analysis to see where we're better and where we're worse. We pick, say, three or four competitors and, beyond the description, give a score on a scale from −2 to +3: how we compare and where we stand against the competition. A very common mistake in most online stores is looking through rose-tinted glasses: we have this, we have that, we run social media, after all. But how do we run it? Then I ask: "OK, and what does your social media strategy look like?" When I ask social media agencies, "What's the strategy, meaning how do you plan to grow this brand over a given time frame?", I most often hear: "Here we'll run ads, dynamic remarketing for promotions; here we'll boost sponsored posts from the fan page." And it runs on such basics that it makes my blood boil. Sorry, I won't swear, but it really annoys me. A social media strategy seems simple, because everyone thinks: you have to be on social media. But it really takes very careful thought.
I have the big advantage that I don't produce the results on my own. Behind the results are also my trusted partners, whom I've checked and tested in many areas: social media, SEO, ads, all the traffic channels. For example, I have a brilliant freelancer who knows this market inside out. All he has to do is a full audit of what's going on, and every store owner's eyes open, because it turns out how many components there are. In short: the cold and warm traffic split I mentioned. What we say to cold traffic, because that's a whole structure, and what happens next with warm traffic once we've captured it. You can even do competitor analysis across three sales stages: pre-sale, ideally with three defined KPIs, the sale itself and post-sale. Does anyone do this and set goals for those stages? OK, people set an annual sales plan, but what about after the sale? What's our goal after the purchase? What's next in our messaging? Most often, after the purchase, the newsletter goes out, email marketing, basic marketing automation flows, meaning abandoned cart recovery, browsed products, the most worn-out standard there is. But you can do this at a much higher level, as long as the technology allows it. For example, a month after the purchase: how's the product working out? Are you happy with it? You can automate things like that, and they make a big difference, because the customer thinks: "Wow, this brand is asking me how the product is working and whether I'm happy." Small, simple things. How many brands do it? Even if we talked about it now, we'd have to think really hard about who actually does.
Maciek: To give a good example.
Checkout bugs that kill conversion
Michał: Yes, because I don't mean a review request after the purchase along the lines of "Hey, thanks for your purchase, wonderful. How would you rate it?" Back to competitor analysis: I also pay a lot of attention to UX, but specifically to how the differentiators are placed. Two days ago, on Wednesday, I had a consultation where we went through the UX of two stores on the same technology: one a fashion brand, the other more beauty. After going through the purchase path, especially the checkout, it turned out there was a major screw-up. In that store 70% of sales went through parcel lockers, and when you chose a parcel locker, a map opened and a loading wheel just kept spinning.
Maciek: A conversion killer.
Michał: A real conversion killer. You scrolled the screen and the wheel kept spinning. Wait a moment, still spinning. A disaster. Commercially, a total disaster.
Maciek: Why didn't anyone check it? How did it not show up in testing?
Michał: It was a newly launched store.
Maciek: All the more reason.
Michał: Yes, but it had been live for a while. After launch it had been checked and the problem wasn't there, but then something, pardon the expression, broke and crashed. Or another example, because I try to describe things with concrete cases, from two weeks ago. Also a store, a sports brand. Suddenly there was a very big drop in sales, down 50–60%. What's going on? All it took was creating a custom purchase path report in GA4 explorations, step by step: add to cart, checkout and so on. It turned out that something in the purchase process meant the cart numbers were still the same, but after entering checkout and completing the purchase it was a disaster, down 60%. I'll say right away that we never found out what caused it, because the problem disappeared, but during that time the technology had some issue.
Maciek: Probably it simply wasn't possible to complete the purchase.
Michał: Or it was very difficult or complicated. And everyone assumes stores work great and are fast. Mostly, when we're on fiber, they really are fast. In theory people say we shouldn't worry about store speed, because everyone has fiber and very good internet.
Maciek: And at the same time fashion stores get 80 or 90% of their traffic from mobile, right?
Michał: Yes, there it's even in the nineties. And in revenue too: I have a client who currently gets over 90% of revenue from mobile. I laugh, because every year at conferences it was the year of mobile, the year of mobile, the year of mobile.
Maciek: We know that story.
Michał: And the year of mobile never came, until it finally did, probably around 2020. That roughly coincides with COVID. That's when I noticed revenue starting to shift toward mobile.
Pricing with products that bring traffic and products that make money
Maciek: Back to the analysis…
Michał: Back to competitor analysis itself: there are a lot of areas. Pricing again. If we don't analyze pricing, how do we want to position ourselves? There are two criteria. Are we a multi-brand store with a wide range of standardized products? Then the question is how to position our pricing. For example, we need to push up margins, because otherwise the business won't add up. Then you have to build a whole pricing strategy and segmentation. The electronics industry does this very well, with its low margins: RTV Euro AGD, Media Expert, x-kom and so on. Extra services, an extended warranty, carrying the item into your home are the components that save the margin in that business. Because as we know, margins in electronics aren't great. The basket saves the day, along with a lot of marketing, those back bonuses.
Maciek: When you go through a purchase at Media Expert, all that upselling at the cart stage is almost irritating.
Michał: Yes. It's also about finding a balance. Whether it's RTV Euro AGD or Media Expert, people find it irritating, because it's built so that it's hard to click "I don't want extra services." That's how it's designed. I'd think about it from a business perspective, because when they analyze it, it probably pays off, but how many customers might drop out because of it? And when it comes to differentiators and advantages, Media Expert is a great example of something obvious: fast shipping. Many times I needed something the next day. Their logistics cut-off was very late, around 9 p.m. I believe, so I placed an order at 8:40 p.m. and had it the next day, when competitors didn't offer anything like it. I'd bet that's a very big differentiator and advantage in that industry. I haven't analyzed the whole market for it, but when I checked RTV Euro AGD, for example, they absolutely didn't have it. At x-kom the cut-offs were much earlier. That's why, when I need something fast, I buy straight from Media Expert. Oh, and pricing segmentation. I'm not sure if I'm going too deep.
Maciek: Very interesting stuff.
Michał: If so, rein me in and we'll move on. There's a very good advisory firm, Simon-Kucher & Partners, that specializes in pricing. What I know today also comes from my corporate work, because I had the means and tools to check and test certain things. Especially at the online pharmacy, which I built from scratch and grew, where there was an absolute ban on advertising. All I really had left was building organic traffic, or Ceneo, meaning price comparison sites. And what does that mean for the business? Obviously, falling margins. So pricing works like this: we have a traffic builder product that brings customers to the store, but as a multi-brand store we have to do everything we can to get the customer to add high-margin products. I'm not even talking about services, but high-margin products.
Maciek: So it's a bestseller whose margin we cut on purpose?
Michał: Yes. Let me give an example from that industry: in online pharmacies, infant formula like Bebilon or Bebiko accounted for a good dozen or so percent of the whole store's sales, because everyone bought it online in large quantities. A bestseller, no question, so we had to figure out how to get the customer to buy something besides the formula that would give us a chance to make up the margin. So there's the traffic builder, then the product standard, a product with a better margin, and only then the profit generator, the third element, which has…
Maciek: A real margin.
Michał: …a real margin. In this case, for example, private label brands. At Dr Max, say, we suggest a Dr Max-branded painkiller, because obviously its margin is on a completely different level than a product bought from Polpharma or another pharmaceutical manufacturer.
An honest analysis and differentiators hidden on the "About us" page
Michał: I'm not sure how deep to go, because there are many components and I could keep going. But to sum up this part: it's very important to do the competitor analysis honestly with yourself, accepting that competitors may be better and have advantages. Seeing their advantages, we also know which direction we should go. And it may turn out that we have great differentiators that just don't come through enough. Very often the good stuff is hidden deeper, on the "About us" page. Sometimes that's where the crème de la crème is, nicely written by the owner: the brand was founded because…, our advantages and differentiators are these. Really well written. But then I ask the client: where do you communicate this? On the home page, somewhere less important, on the product page? "Well, on 'About us'." Go into GA4 and see what percentage of traffic gets there.
Maciek: Who even goes there, right?
Tomek: Yes. How deep you go into each branch of these threads shows how complex this topic really is. We could probably talk about it for a very long time, but…
Michał: A whole day, easily.
Tomek: Exactly. That's probably also what your course is about, which we're going to talk about today.
Michał: That's exactly what we go through.
Tomek: This is where we'll pause the episode. There's a lot of material, and I assume your notebooks are full. We'll pick up the conversation in the next part, where Michał will talk about more aspects of scaling a store.
Part two of the conversation: Michał Pieprzak, Ekomersiak: What is hindering the growth of your store – part 2 (in Polish, with an English transcript).



